Being new to the Fediverse can be a scary place when it comes to the management of time.

New users of Mastodon ask me if that's enough. Should they also be on Pixelfed or micro.blog, too?

I ask if they ever used Facebook, Twitter and Instagram at the same time. If they do, or did, then the same proves true, here.

Be ubiquitous! Create in many spaces! Your micro.blog posts can be sent to Mastodon, as can your Pixelfed posts.

Be everywhere. Let your thoughts infect, and influence, everything.

@david I'd be more cautious -- each one of those platforms you mention is both a tech stack with its own features, as well as a specific circle of humans you expect to reach with your posts. Mastodon has the right mix of features to switch my Twitter peeps over, but the people connected to my FB and Insta are much less adventurous -- AND the #Fediverse tools to replace those are not quite at feature parity yet - #NSFNormals. Worst case: You post all over the Fedi and nobody's listening! #YMMV

@tedcurran

I'm speaking to those who are trying to leave social media but want replacements, but they don't know if Mastodon fills all the holes.

I encourage them to experiment with what's available and find out what works best for them.

@david @tedcurran

FWIW, I hate to see people having to create multiple identities as a bit of a hurdle to engage with in those different ways.

If I want my Fediverse identity to post both a microblogging message and Pixelfed type content, it stinks to have to wrangle between split identities instead of having it all tied to one.

I BELIEVE has the capability to support single identities across services, though I don't know if it's ever really been implemented.

But I really hope development of programs like go in that direction so that someday, sooner rather than later, a person can present a single identity that crosses between services.

@volkris @david Agreed it's not ideal. I feel like I've heard about efforts to develop decentralized personal identity keychains, where you can lend your identity to a service without that service OWNING your identity, you own it. I don't recall what it's called or if it's ready for prime time yet. Identity as a service? I imagine it's complicated, as identifying oneself inevitably is.

@tedcurran @volkris

I don't think singular identity services work very well because everyone has to play along, and once you're in you can't get out -- in the USA I think of the Social Security Number that was, for many years, used as an identifier for government services until it then became a "one stop shop" for identity theft.

I do like the idea that one account would link every service -- and in some way we have that with profiles here and "verification" on one level.

@david @tedcurran

To clarify, it's completely up to the user as to how to use/project identities.

For example, a single human might choose to at least have one professional identity and one hobby identity. Or heaven forbid a trolling identity.
Heck, they could choose to start a new identity for each season of the year.

As it stands technological limitations require an identity to be split between different services. It sure would be nice if those barriers could come down, leaving it up to the user to decide how to represent each identity they wish to be.

@volkris @tedcurran

A lot of people have multiple Mastodon accounts on different servers -- so that would have to be somehow stopped if this were ever to take effect.

I don't see that happening soon because the whole idea that is encouraged is that you can be multiple places on Mastodon at the same time -- using various identities -- and that's just fine from what I understand.

@david @tedcurran

There's no reason the two couldn't coexist.

Have multiple disjointed accounts if you want. Register the same identity to multiple instances if you want.

You do you.

@volkris @tedcurran

Doesn't that defeat the idea that you know the identity of the person you're dealing with -- don't we want the ID to go both ways?

We don't want one person claiming to be your friend, and then troll you on another account, right? There needs to be a unification of purpose, or the whole idea appears to fall apart.

Follow

@6al @tedcurran @david

Good point, and that would also help with some of the revocation issues brought up in a thread I came across.

Maybe it's a bit complicated because Fediverse IS centralized, just centralized to each of the federated instances.

(We should reconsider calling it decentralized. Maybe federated instead of decentralized.)

I don't know how nicely the centralized instances would play with differently centralized CAs.

Although with https already in the mix, I suppose they already are.

What a mess :)

@volkris @6al @tedcurran

It is a mess, and maybe unsolvable. People get on their "instances" and the Admin runs them like Little Elons if they wish -- banning, blocking, protecting -- and that's the beauty and danger of what's happening.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.