The fact that insurrectionists are on the floor of Congress to debate -- anything -- is damning. Has a powerful nation ever been so powerless?
#gqp #gop #republicans #jan6 #january6 #jan6th #january6th #politics #uspol #uspolitics #news #insurrection #gaetz #mattgaetz
Well it's about democracy.
You might not like these people, but they were elected by their constituents to be representatives in the democratic institution.
When you talk about a powerful nation being powerless in contrast to these democratic results, well it comes across as awfully authoritarian, maybe even fascist.
I'm sorry you don't like how the democratic process worked out, but to use rhetoric about the power of the state to oppose democracy? That's troubling.
@volkris This isn't about the democratic process. These individuals subverted our laws to try to steal an election and organized a coup attempt. Those individuals should be held accountable in the courts but have largely subverted consequences.
Having no accountability for seditious acts is what I find troubling. If organized violence and fake electors are part of the democratic process, I don't know what to say.
Having laws enforced to protect democracy shouldn't be considered undemocratic.
It is about the democratic process because they were democratically elected to the democratic institution.
You are welcome to want to use the state to punish them. But let's be clear that you're talking about applying authority that would subvert the democratic process that elected them.
That happens from time to time in history.
The results tend to be less than ideal.
Your general argument seems to hinge on the idea that holding alleged criminals accountable is rooted in "want[ing] the state to punish them." Here, you've made the idea of justice seem perverse.
In addition, you insinuate these figures being democratically elected makes legal pursuits against them into a witch hunt. Again, justice is made perverse.
Voters can elect who they choose. But our justice system should hold people accountable regardless of whether they hold office.
Not at all. Prosecute away. There's nothing to stop prosecutors from prosecuting democratically elected representatives.
It's a completely separate issue.
But it just has nothing to do with their being democratically elected, and it is dangerous territory to talk about overriding voters or undermining the democratic process because one would rather authorities bring down a hammer.
@volkris My original post was intending to speak to the powerlessness of our justice system to bring alleged traitors to justice. But I can see, with your third paragraph, how the phrasing can get mixed up with the wrong message.
I'm going to amend the post here since we've got an edit feature.
@stopgopfox @volkris
As you give thought to your edits, there's also the question of what actions rise to the level of criminality.
Is it criminal to vote not to certify the electors?
Is it criminal to assist in the submission of fake electors?
Is it criminal to show people around the Capital knowing they are planning to storm the capital?
IMO, no, yes & yes, but are there criminal statutes that fit?
Is there evidence to convict?
One thing it's not is cut & dried.
@joeinwynnewood @volkris With the fake electors, an article about Michigan specifically mentions forgery of a public record and election law forgery.
I agree with you that not voting to certify electors is far trickier to prosecute.
Finally, with showing those around the capital? If an investigation reveals any knowledge of the rioters' intent, at the very least aim for conspiracy to commit a criminal offense. That can be up to 5 years in prison in DC.
The whole "fake electors" conspiracy theory is based on missing that the US legal system requires token gestures to stand up and present somebody who has been harmed for the sake of standing.
It's not some weird conspiracy theory; it's just a standard legal fiction.
People getting all upset over this particular element just really don't understand how legal system works in the US. And that's a shame because they are all too often falling for a conspiracy theory based on lack of understanding of how the legal system works.
@volkris @stopgopfox I don't think that's the basis for the potential criminality in this instance. IANAL, but I read/listen to the musings of a few good ones, and the crux is conspiracy to defraud and having defrauding the US Government by having sent fraudulent elector certificates to the National Archives.
What to know about the Trump ‘fake electors’ scheme
https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/27/politics/fake-electors-explainer/index.html