Show newer

@meowski

Sure thing I can post a source. In fact I already did earlier in the conversation, it has almost the exact wording I use (reporductive organs, function):

"Either of the two divisions, designated female and male, by which most organisms are classified on the basis of their reproductive organs and functions"

-- The American Heritage Medical Dictionary

Notice the definition says nothing about genetics.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@a7

It is such an obvious fact it really doesnt need to be expressed as anything more than common sense or accepted science... I entierly expect the few morons who cant see past their nose will come out of the wood work.. thats not who the post is for, but it does serve my purpose to know who are the morons who arent worth giving attention to in future conversations and who are bright enough to have valuable input on future discussions..

gotta throw a goose egg out from time to time to weed out the idiots and keep the timeline clean.

@yarra @georgia

@georgia

The OP was never about the physical act of sex, we are talking about what sex a person is.. so if you are talking about something else, thats fine, thats not the topic.

@yarra @a7

@meowski

According to biologists sex characteristics are how sex is determined yes.. saying it isnt so doesnt make it so.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@georgia

Yup as expected the medical dictionary says pretty much exactly what I just said, that sex is defined by ones reproductive organs (not the gametes) and ones function. The exact wording is as follows:

" Either of the two divisions, designated female and male, by which most organisms are classified on the basis of their reproductive organs and functions"

-- The American Heritage Medical Dictionary

@Agni @yarra @a7

@meowski

And that is incorrect.. the genes are of course one aspect that determines sex, it is NOT the only one. The expression (what you physically develop) and your function (how you behave and what you can do) are all aspects of what determines sex, and in fact the more common definition you will find.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@georgia

looks like someone needs to open up a medical dictionary. They are defined by their reproductive organs and the function (expression) of their genetics, which entails a rather long complicated list of what constitutes function in any one species.

You will never find any medical dictionary defining sex **solely** on the basis of gametes, in fact you likely wont even find the word games in the definition in most medical dictionaries.

One sec let me get mind and find their exact wording.

@Agni @yarra @a7

@SwampWitchHerbalist

Notice the word defect doesnt even show up once in that long quotation you just pasted....

And no they dont only effect males or females.. some result in people on one end of the spectrum or the other, other conditions do not.

@a7

@pthenq1

Yup, it was an injustice, and expressing that in ways that doesnt kill large numbers of people are great... doesnt excuse the way most people responded however during a pandemic. I said it at the time as well. A hell of a lot of people died because people decided to ignore the life and safety of others in how they expressed their right to protest that injustice. There were better ways to do it.

@Science

@a7

Not everyone, just the actual morons that are talking like third graders.. Thankfully you and others with that level of maturity are a small dying minority.

@Agni @yarra @georgia

@meowski

None of what you just said is actually true in terms of biology and really never has been.. thats just you trying to fit an already well established concept into your preconception of what it should be..

What you are talking about is one of many sex characteristics, their genes. But they are not (by professional biologists) considered the defacto determinant of sex. In fact genetic expression is generally favored over the genes themselves when it comes to sexing organisms due to the contradictions that arise by looking solely at ones genes.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@georgia

No your confusing the act of sex, with the sex of the organism engaging in it.. The act of sex does not define the sex of the organism engaged in it.. your trying to warp the actual science behind how animals are sexed with your own biases, and it doesnt match the reality.

Infertile women, for example are still women, they can not produce children, have no gametes to speak of, but are women because, quite simply, sex is not determines strictly by your gametes but by a whole list of features. Those features are not an "all or nothing" deal and thus sex, while generally favoring one end of the spectrum or the other, is still quite clearly on a spectrum.

@Agni @yarra @a7

@meowski

> 2% is a very high estimate and probably wrong. estimates are as low as .01% or less

No its not an estimate that is likely to be wrong or right, its a matter of definition that can give a pretty large variation on the number.

the 2% figure uses the broadest possible definition of intersex. If that is the definition being used its a perfectly reasonable figure and likely not overestimated at all. The thing is the definition may be too broad to be useful for some contexts, so not that its wrong, just that it doesnt apply to certain conversations. A more narrow definition of intersex can lead to much smaller numbers.

This is in fact a common problem when we talk about labeling things that exist on a spectrum... if we consider the 98% center part of the male-female spectrum as intersex and male and female (non-intersex) being the 1% extremes on either end you are going to get a very different figure than if you divide up that spectrum a very different way.

Its for this reason it isnt even useful to talk about who is or is not intersex, its a spectrum, there is no hard cut off point.

> birth defects are a spectrum. sex is not a spectrum. the way sexual reproduction works is there are 2 gametes, one from male and female.

No thats not at all correct or in line with the science. While sexual reproduction is one aspect of sex, and is one of the many factors that go into to determining how scientists identify and classify sexes, it is actually a much smaller part than you seem to realize.

for example by your definition any animals that happens to be infertile would not have a sex of male or female since they nether produce gametes nor reproduce, this would be wholly false of course and infertility doesnt negate your sex.

Likewise we have all sorts of situations where the animals themselves are sexed on the male-female spectrum yet do not require the opposite sex to procreate at all.

Literally nothing about this statement is true other than a grossly oversimplified grade-school explanation of sex, which is fine for little kids, but we are adults, and you should know better, it certainly doesnt match up with how scientists have always handled sex.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@thestrongest

How does that expose a paradox... people disagreeing on which of two statements is fact, even within the same community, doesnt imply a paradox. It just means there are unanswered questions that are still open for debate.

I think its fairly obvious men and womens brains on average are different. The issue only arrises when one assumes a woman must have a brain identical to the "average" womans brain, or a man must as an individual have a brain identical to the average male brain.

@icedquinn @meowski @StarAStar

Just wanted to share a little chart showing the likely effect of the mass BLM protests over George floyd compared to the COVID-19 recorded new cases count.

To be clear, I think Floyd's death was an injustice and I support the idea of opposing it at every level. But it was the number one biggest factor that caused the COVID epidemic to resurge out of control and we never recovered from the surge seen during the protest and even now this new surge we are seeing is partially fueled by the effects of those protests.

The irony here is the left have been the most vocal about COVID and blamed Trump for not seeing enough success in battling it as a central point in their entire presidential debate... yet they are also the ones who caused more loss of life and a more prolific spread of the diseases than anyone else when it served their agenda, and had the gall to try to blame that on Trump or republicans.

After seeing months of liberals abusing old ladies grocery shopping without a mask on and the like it is pretty disgusting, though typical, to see they are also the ones who caused more a problem than anyone else.

@Science

@meowski

The estimated number is usually a bit closer to 2%, but depends on what your defining as the criteria, so the percentage is hard to pin down.

With that said 1% is a huge number of people, we are still talking many many millions.

One can of course argue that intersex is a minority of the population and you wouldnt be wrong to do so.. Doesnt change the fact that sex is a spectrum and that these people exist on the spectrum at a point other than its extremes.

Its also important to note that while sex is a spectrum and being truely in the middle is the minority it doesnt make the importance of sex as a spectrum any less. There are males who will be close enough to the male end of the spectrum not be labeled as intersexed but still have some variation and female like qualities in low proportions (for example a lower than normal testosterone level or higher than normal estrogen levels).. We might call them men but recognizing the existance of the spectrum is as important for them as those in the middle.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@georgia

Who said anything about a third sex? I have pointed out several times its not about there being a third sex, its about there not being 2 discrete sexes but rather a continuous spectrum of sexes between 2 extremes.

Likewise the existance of ovotestis **is** a spectrum, and I linked a scientific paper that even goes into the expectrum of the ovotestis and one way on measure wear on the spectrum a particular person's ovotestis happen to be.

This should be obvious as it has tissue with properties of each end of the spectrum and can develop closer to one end or the other to any degree at all on that spectrum.

@Agni @yarra @a7

@georgia

Thats actually not that far off from the science... though usually more like testical, ovotestis, ovaries. It is the gonads that exist on a spectrum more so than the gametes, though there are also abnormalities in gametes.

@Agni @yarra @a7

@icedquinn Well no one is under much obligation to teach anyone else. That is unfortunate of course, but you have to keep in mind scientists like myself usually have a lot of time demanded of us by conspiracy theorists like flat earthers, or the earth is only 4,000 years old or whatever, for the most part climate change deniers often (though not always) arent much different. It would be trivial to step someone through step by step how we can be certain of climate change (as I said the evidence and conclusion is relatively trivial).. The problem is most of the time these people arent there to learn why climate change is true, they are there to argue their side ad infinitum and just waste everyones time, and eventually after however long the debate evolves into "well how can I trust scientists they are paid mooonnniiieeessss".

If you or anyone has a sincere desire to understand why human caused climate change is real, and dont understand how the dots are connected I will always be happy to walk you through it, but if you already come in with your mind made up and without the expertise to validate that, then its likely going to be a waste of my time to try.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.