Show newer

@wiggles

Well few things..

1) you are correct that the examples I gave were not necceseraly fertile or healthy conditions. However there are plenty of intersex individuals who are perfectly healthy, so thats not really much of a point overall.

2) yes intersex people do tend to be infertile (though not all are)..

However, how does either of those 2 points prove that sex is any less of a spectrum? Sounds like what your saying is that people at either extreme of the spectrum tend to be physically more healthy, which is fine, but doesnt negate the fact that its a spectrum.

@realcaseyrollins

@wishgranter14

Wow your a little slow on the uptake. The point was made to mock the absurdity of the claim I was responding to. The whole point was to show how absurd it is and it is presumed a reader wouldnt be so dense as to think I was making the point in earnest (though I seem to have underestimated you)...

Literally the whole point of the statement was to show how absurd it is.

@wowaname @meowski @ArdanianRight @SwampWitchHerbalist @a7

@ArdanianRight

Sure, no one is claiming there is. A persons sex, however, is not defined or limited by their reproductive role (as is obvious by the fact that a reproductive woman is still considered a woman).

@wowaname @meowski @SwampWitchHerbalist @a7

@ArdanianRight

So a woman born infertile or post menopause is not a woman, she has no sex since she can no longer reproduce?

Think what you want but thats just absurd.

@wowaname @meowski @SwampWitchHerbalist @a7

@charliebrownau@liberdon.com

Trans isnt even the topic of the OP. We are talking about how people are born, not if or how they choose to transition later in life, thats a different topic.

@meowski @SwampWitchHerbalist @a7

@meowski

yes it had transrights hashtag, it effects their rights, My statement asserted nothing about trans people however, so the point still stands.

>you've been indoctrinated. you're in a radical left wing environment so you probably feel obligated to make these idiotic statements to suck up to the power structure.

What the hell are you talking about. Trump and his family have literally had dinner with my family before he ran for president, as have quite a few republicans congressmen. Not only is my environment clearly not only left, I've had direct involvement with conservative politicians.

> it takes a special kind of person to do real science in such a hostile and highly politicized academic climate, so i don't entirely blame you for this partisan sniveling

Keep talking out of your ass, you dont know the first thing about what environment I'm in.

> but if you do it on fedi you're going to get some pushback.

It had exactly the result I wanted it to have on the fedi.. It exposed the value, contribution, and education of many people to help me decide how much time or energy to put into future interactions with them. I got exactly the outcome I was hoping for, no complaints

@SwampWitchHerbalist @a7

@xyfdi@gameliberty.club

I did some pretty extensive research on this when I looking it over using the techniques I was taught when i worked for the government modeling disease proliferation. Its pretty confident IMO to blame this on the protests.

@Science

@meowski

I never mentioned trans once.. intersex isnt trans.. Trans is a person who is undergoing surgery to transition, intersex is someone born far enough away from the extremes of the spectrum to not consider them fitting descriptions.

@SwampWitchHerbalist @a7

@SwampWitchHerbalist

1) none of what you posted refered to intersex as being a defect

2) some causes of intersex can cause defects, others do not.

A prime example would be androgen insensitivity syndrome. The person will have XY chromosomes but appear entierly female without any indication on the outside of being intersexed in many cases. Nothing about that would be seen by a casual observer as being a defect.

@a7

@djsumdog

Funny, was thinking the same thing about you.. you literally pulled percentages out of your ass twice (mine came from actual numbers published by doctors)... go figure.

@icedquinn @meowski @StarAStar

@meowski

Here is a more nuanced paper that disagrees with what your saying and goes into details about how sex detmination is **not** strictly chromosomal but depends on the **expression** of those genes and thus must consider the entire pathway (literally what I said earlier):

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/

It goes into some detail as to how various sexes can and do arise contrary to their genes.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@realcaseyrollins

the controversy today was spurred by a congresswoman literally saying there are only 2 sexes, not genders. In fact she went out of her way to have the word sexes printed on her little sign... So clearly your not speaking accurately of conservatives.

twitter.com/RepMTG/status/1364

@djsumdog

No the number is 2% if we use the broadest definition of intersex, small when other definitions are used.

Thre is no specific % however that is "right" since sex is a spectrum, so the percentage is defined wholly by where you place the cutoff. So its a self referential measure that really doesnt help much.

@icedquinn @meowski @StarAStar

@meowski

No gonads (sex organs) are primary sex characteristic, your own image says it int he first line.

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@meowski

Your link literally disagrees with you and says pretty much exactly what I already said, that sex is determined by your reproductive organs (gonads) and your function.. The image you just posted says exactly that, it is determined byt he gonads.

As we determined earlier the genes is certainly something that determines that, and often goes hand in hand, but it is not the defining quality (as your own image you just pasted states).

@StarAStar @icedquinn

@djsumdog

The 99.9% figure is wholly false. Though you would be correct if you said that true intersex in the middle of the spectrum is rare.

As for if they can reproduce or not, I wont argue that many can not... so what? A person doesnt cease having a sex when/if they become infertile. That really doesnt mean jack.

@StarAStar

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.