This graph has been passed around the internet to prove that more teenage boys are identifying as #conservative, but the graph is a lie.
Mostly.
First, take a good look at that x-axis. It goes from 10 to 30, not zero to 100. We see about a 13-point drop in boys identifying as #liberals, a 6-point increase in boys identifying as #conservatives. This is not a substantial change.
But wait, there's more...
@liveposting
This survey didn't just check two categories. It checked four:
• #Liberal,
• #Conservative,
• #Centrist, and
• #Radical.
Yes, left and right radicals were grouped together. Good survey. ![]()
But consider how a radical identifies. A #leftist wears that label on their sleeve, while a right-winger hides it and pretends to be a conservative instead. In other words, this chart is hiding how many people now have left-of liberal-ideals, within the missing 60% of respondents.
@liveposting
In a graph about how people identify, I think you're reaching a bit when complaining that it presented how people identify.
If the chart is about identification, then having ideals is a different matter, so you're complaining that the chart measured what it said instead of what, I suppose, you would have preferred to study.
I didn't say anything about your complaints about the scaling.
But it jumped out at me that you were making this particular complaint, about the graph about identity focusing on identity.
I would have other questions about this research, about its methodology, that go far beyond how they scaled their graph, but then, I don't actually think this claim is particularly substantial enough to track it down.
Oh, no, not at all! I didn't find your claim the least bit interesting. It comes across as anecdotal projection relying on subjective and normative comparisons with little actual insight.
@volkris except for the insight you went out of your way to say you didn't dispute, correct?
You are incorrect, and I just didn't want to repeat myself above.
You seem to have misunderstood what I wrote above, but again I just feel like I would be repeating myself should I restate it, so that doesn't look productive.
@volkris I'm glad you're admitting to finding value in my analysis. Thank you!
Why don't you pick out a thing that upsets you and we can talk about it? I'd love to improve my analysis for someone as reasonable as you
Well that's one part I think I can clarify without repeating: upset? No I'm not upset. I just got a kick out of the absurdity of your statement. It made me laugh!
This whole story is not one with enough substance to get anybody upset over, IMO.
@volkris so you're specifically interested in my claim that left-wing radicals tend to identify as radicals, while right-wing radicals tend to identify as conservatives?
How many members of the Socialist Rifle Association would you say identify as liberals, versus members of the Proud Boys identifying as conservatives?