This graph has been passed around the internet to prove that more teenage boys are identifying as #conservative, but the graph is a lie.

Mostly.

First, take a good look at that x-axis. It goes from 10 to 30, not zero to 100. We see about a 13-point drop in boys identifying as #liberals, a 6-point increase in boys identifying as #conservatives. This is not a substantial change.

But wait, there's more...
@liveposting

This survey didn't just check two categories. It checked four:
• #Liberal,
• #Conservative,
• #Centrist, and
• #Radical.
Yes, left and right radicals were grouped together. Good survey. :eyeroll:

But consider how a radical identifies. A #leftist wears that label on their sleeve, while a right-winger hides it and pretends to be a conservative instead. In other words, this chart is hiding how many people now have left-of liberal-ideals, within the missing 60% of respondents.
@liveposting

@nus

In a graph about how people identify, I think you're reaching a bit when complaining that it presented how people identify.

If the chart is about identification, then having ideals is a different matter, so you're complaining that the chart measured what it said instead of what, I suppose, you would have preferred to study.

@liveposting

@volkris

You don't understand the basic concepts of a false dichotomy and skewing graphs to make them look more extreme than they are? I learned that stuff in elementary school, and I'm an American.

Here's a helpful resource:
statisticshowto.com/probabilit

@liveposting

@nus

I didn't say anything about your complaints about the scaling.

But it jumped out at me that you were making this particular complaint, about the graph about identity focusing on identity.

I would have other questions about this research, about its methodology, that go far beyond how they scaled their graph, but then, I don't actually think this claim is particularly substantial enough to track it down.

@volkris so you're specifically interested in my claim that left-wing radicals tend to identify as radicals, while right-wing radicals tend to identify as conservatives?

How many members of the Socialist Rifle Association would you say identify as liberals, versus members of the Proud Boys identifying as conservatives?

@nus

Oh, no, not at all! I didn't find your claim the least bit interesting. It comes across as anecdotal projection relying on subjective and normative comparisons with little actual insight.

@volkris except for the insight you went out of your way to say you didn't dispute, correct?

@nus

You are incorrect, and I just didn't want to repeat myself above.

You seem to have misunderstood what I wrote above, but again I just feel like I would be repeating myself should I restate it, so that doesn't look productive.

@volkris I'm glad you're admitting to finding value in my analysis. Thank you!

Why don't you pick out a thing that upsets you and we can talk about it? I'd love to improve my analysis for someone as reasonable as you

Follow

@nus

Well that's one part I think I can clarify without repeating: upset? No I'm not upset. I just got a kick out of the absurdity of your statement. It made me laugh!

This whole story is not one with enough substance to get anybody upset over, IMO.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.