Show newer

@rat_attakk

What does the average body fat of the sexes have to do with the discussion? We are not talking about average members of society, so average numbers tell you nothing about the topic we are discussing.

you would have to compare the body fat percentage of the top performing athletes in the same sport and see if there is a significant different to really have any useful data.

I'd imagine you'd find sports where low body fat results in superior performance men and women at the top of their respective leagues would have more similar body fat

@icedquinn

I should point out there are sports which are complete sex neutral where women hold world records over men or even the majority of world records over men. Though they dont tend to be the sorts of sports that rely on running or power.. free diving is the most notable one dominated by women

@rat_attakk
@icedquinn

@rat_attakk

Not really, no one is stopping them from continuing to do womens league if they wanted to in addition to a mixed league.

@icedquinn

@icedquinn

Any ideal solution in my mind wouldnt give women any sort of special adjustments. weight class is probably one of the best normalizations I could think of but I dont have any real data to say how well it would work, or any data to suggest it wouldnt work.

@rat_attakk

@rat_attakk

So? I never once claimed women are **overall** going to be superior to men in much (only area i know of where they dominate over men is total distance traveled, particularly extreme long-distance hiking over the course of months)...

We are talking about after weight normalization, which none of the records you just mentioned take into account.

@icedquinn

@rat_attakk

a woman isnt wasting energy on producing milk or a child if she is an athelete, she isnt pregnant at the time. The resources arent being diverted there.

That said they are probably likely to be smaller chested as tends to appear to be the case at least. but that likely has to do with being low-fat overall.

@icedquinn

@rat_attakk

Being distributed different just means women will be better at some parts, men better at others, for the same muscle mass.. A woman might jump higher and a man might run faster, therefore women and men would be suited for different positions on a team. But ultimately if their muscle mass is equivalent they should have comparable performance if your considering across the spectrum.

@icedquinn

@icedquinn

Thats not unusual for men or women in sports, in fact its the norm. We did it regularly in our high school wrestling team even. Its pretty much standard practice in any weight based sport (wrestling being one).

@rat_attakk

@icedquinn Assuming that is true im not sure it is a counter argument here. Assuming the analogy carried over to men and women at all at worst it implies a woman might need to spend more time training than a man to be in the same league as him, which is fine by me.. but youd still get women on equal footing with men at the lower weight classes..

The end result would be that the top weight classes would likely be all or mostly men, and then the bottom weight classes or slightly above youd have women right up there with men, it would just be that due to natural differences you might reason that you have the best of the best of the women competing against average level men, they are on equal footing within their league all the same and that just nature, but it would work.

@rat_attakk

do you have any data on mma fighting or something? Obviously they have a different figure but when all your weight is developed into muscle that just means youll have different superior abilities on each side at best not any side being at a greater advantage overall.

@icedquinn

@meowski

You wouldnt.. transexuals and transgendered people do not want their own bathrooms or an elimination of sports leagues all together.. They want to be included, not to have other excluded.

@icedquinn

@icedquinn Other way around, I've never seen any data to suggest a man is superior to a woman of the same weight class and similar training.

@icedquinn Seems to me there would be better ways to solve that as well.. Simply have sports be neutral to genders, then do all sports by weight class, problem solved, men will dominate the higher weight class divisions, women will be on equal footing at lower weight classes.. a woman and a man of equal weight, both trained to have low body fat will have equivelant muscle mass and performance.

@icedquinn Personally I think we are going about it backwards.. we shouldnt be treating women, or minorities as special groups or give them special treatment (regardless of if they face unique challenges), therefore problem solved, be a minority if you want, who cares.

That isnt that there is no problem or that the problem isnt to be solved. But if we solve the problem for all poor, for example, then by extension we are already helping challenged groups (who are more likely to be poor) as a result.

@Pat regardless we are still talking about societal privilages granted along the lines of ones medical history, which people would be forced to disclose in order to function within society. This alone is unacceptable. At no time should a person in any way should have any obligation to disclose their medical history.

@Pat That doesnt change my stance, which is that I agree with you that its a bad thing (to either be at an advantage or disadvantage due to medical decisions)... but agreeing that it is a bad argument doesnt mean its a logical fallacy is my point.

@cjd

How ya figure? Far more international trade takes place in asian than america, by several orders of magnitude.

@mithrandir

@cjd

Yea which is as i said, american markets will use american units. But international markets use metric.

The reason the american market has more volume doesnt tell you much because your looking at one among many markets, its not a measure of total market volume across all USA.

@mithrandir

@Pat

Very true, my dad is from the middle of nowhere (Montana where you can barely see your neighbor's home from your porch)... anyone out there has seen, held, and used a gun. But rural residents are a minority and most of the population are in or near cities where its not nearly as common.

@Faket

@Pat

Most people go their whole lives in america and maybe see a gun once or twice and only at a shooting range.

Gun ownership isnt rare in terms of percentages but it is highly concentrated and those who own guns tend to be somewhat private about it. so regardless of just how many physical guns there are it is pretty typical to go your whole life in america and never see a gun in person.

@Faket

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.